Vitality Catalyst · Church Revitalization Coach

Tag: gen z

  • THE LEADERSHIP CRISIS CHURCHES DON’T WANT TO TALK ABOUT

    THE LEADERSHIP CRISIS CHURCHES DON’T WANT TO TALK ABOUT

    Why the Future of the Church May Depend on Whether Millennials Can Let Go

    For years, churches and ministry networks have asked the wrong question.

    “How do we reach the next generation?”

    Conferences have been built around it. Books have been written about it. Entire ministries have been designed around understanding younger leaders. Yet despite all the effort, many churches continue struggling to develop and retain emerging leaders.

    The problem may not be that we don’t understand Generation Z.

    The problem may be that we haven’t recognized who the new rising gatekeepers are.
    Millennials.

    Every generation eventually faces the same temptation. The generation that once challenged the establishment eventually becomes the establishment.

    Twenty years ago, Millennials pushed against leadership systems they viewed as outdated. They advocated for transparency, collaboration, authenticity, and innovation. They questioned authority and challenged institutions they believed had become disconnected from reality.

    Today, many Millennials hold executive pastor positions, denominational leadership roles, network leadership positions, and seats on organizational decision-making bodies throughout the Church.

    The question is no longer whether Millennials can challenge the system.
    The question is whether they are willing to be challenged by the generation coming behind them.

    Generation Z is not simply a younger version of Millennials.

    They have been shaped by a fundamentally different world. They grew up during economic uncertainty, social disruption, a global pandemic, and the rapid emergence of artificial intelligence. Unlike Millennials, who adapted to digital technology, Gen Z was born into it.¹

    According to Deloitte’s 2026 Global Gen Z and Millennial Survey, nearly three-quarters of Gen Z respondents report regularly using AI in their daily work and believe they are adapting to technological change faster than many organizations around them.²
    That should concern church leaders.

    While many churches are still discussing digital ministry strategies, Gen Z is already building communities, creating influence, learning leadership, and forming relationships online.

    They are not waiting for permission.

    This reveals one of the greatest blind spots in ministry today.

    Many church leaders still think of digital platforms as tools.

    Generation Z sees them as environments.

    For decades, influence flowed through stages, pulpits, conferences, and organizational hierarchies. Today, influence increasingly flows through communities, creators, content, conversations, and digital ecosystems.

    The next generation understands this instinctively.

    Many church systems do not.

    As a result, organizations often mistake innovation for rebellion and initiative for impatience.

    The reality is that Gen Z is frequently responding to a world that has already changed, while institutions continue to manage the future through yesterday’s frameworks.

    The tension is not simply generational.

    It is philosophical.

    Boomers built structures and a foundation that is fading.

    Generation X built many of the systems.
    Millennials inherited and refined them.
    Generation Z is questioning whether those systems still work and is deconstructing and recalculating.

    Many churches have failed to recognize that distinction.

    At the same time, churches must confront another uncomfortable reality.

    Young leaders are not leaving simply because ministry is difficult.

    Many are leaving because the leadership culture is unhealthy.

    Generation Z has little interest in environments where burnout is celebrated, control is disguised as vision, and loyalty is demanded without accountability.

    Many have witnessed toxic leadership cultures protected for the sake of organizational stability while emerging leaders absorb the consequences.

    Some leaders interpret Gen Z’s unwillingness to tolerate these environments as weakness.

    Their pushback? It may reflect wisdom.

    Learning to recognize unhealthy environments and establish healthy boundaries is not rebellion.

    It is maturity and thinking.

    The Church should not be producing leaders who endlessly endure dysfunction.
    It should be producing leaders who recognize healthy culture, create healthy culture, and refuse to perpetuate unhealthy culture.

    Another challenge facing churches is the assumption that leadership development primarily happens through information transfer.

    It does not.

    Leadership is developed through experience.

    Volunteering develops empathy and humility.

    Side hustles develop grit and initiative.

    Negotiation develops confidence and self-awareness.

    Conflict develops maturity and emotional intelligence.

    Responsibility develops ownership.

    Failure develops resilience.

    No amount of leadership content can replace lived experience.³

    Yet many churches continue to invest heavily in teaching while offering limited opportunities for meaningful responsibility.

    The next generation does not need another leadership podcast.
    They need opportunities to lead.

    The greatest danger facing churches and ministry networks today is not aging leadership.

    It is a leadership bottleneck.

    For decades, succession has been delayed.

    Baby Boomers held on longer.
    Generation X waited longer.
    Millennials are inheriting leadership and increasingly seeking to protect the influence they worked hard to acquire.

    Meanwhile, Generation Z waits…

    Or leaves.

    History consistently demonstrates that organizations decline when leadership opportunities fail to keep pace with emerging talent.⁴

    When gifted young leaders cannot find meaningful responsibility, they create opportunities elsewhere.

    Increasingly, that is exactly what is happening.

    The next generation is launching ministries, building digital communities, creating businesses, developing platforms, and reaching people in ways many traditional organizations still struggle to understand.

    The future of the Church will not belong to leaders who accumulate the most influence.
    It will belong to leaders who give away their influence.

    Leadership is not measured by how long you remain indispensable.

    Leadership is measured by how effectively you develop people who eventually surpass you.⁵

    The future Church does not need more gatekeepers.

    It needs mentors.
    It needs coaches.
    It needs multipliers.
    It needs leaders willing to release authority before they are forced to.

    Most importantly, it needs Millennials willing to avoid repeating the same mistakes they once criticized in previous generations.

    Because every generation eventually becomes the establishment.

    The question is whether that generation has the humility to make room for those who come next.

    The churches and networks that thrive over the next decade will not be the ones that successfully hold onto power.

    They will be the ones who successfully pass it on.

    FOOTNOTES
    ¹ Jean M. Twenge, Generations (New York: Atria Books, 2023).
    ² Deloitte, 2026 Gen Z and Millennial Survey, surveying more than 22,500 respondents across 44 countries.
    ³ David Kinnaman and Mark Matlock, Faith for Exiles (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 2019).
    ⁴ John P. Kotter, Leading Change (Boston: Harvard Business School Press, 1996).
    ⁵ James M. Kouzes and Barry Z. Posner, The Leadership Challenge, 7th Edition (Hoboken: Wiley, 2023).

     

    Originally published on the Church Vitality Network.

  • Revitalizing Faith: The Call to Transform the American Church

    Revitalizing Faith: The Call to Transform the American Church

    The American church stands at a pivotal crossroads in an era marked by shifting religious landscapes. Recent data from Ed Stetzer’s comprehensive growing research revealed at Exponential with Barna, and Gloo reveals both challenging trends and unexpected opportunities that demand our attention. As Christian identity continues its decades-long decline across the nation, a surprising new pattern emerges—a potential plateau in religious disengagement that offers a critical moment for renewal and multiplication.

    The Reality We Face

    The statistics paint a sobering picture. As Stetzer explains, “Christian identity is on the decline. You can actually see the way people identify in 2009 as Christian, it was substantially higher than it was in 2024.” This decline extends beyond mere identity—weekly church attendance has steadily decreased, and the importance of religious faith has diminished even among those who still call themselves Christians.

    Perhaps most striking is what Stetzer calls “the biggest story of religion in the last 30 years”—the dramatic rise of religious “nones,” those who claim no religious affiliation whatsoever. This trend has reshaped America’s religious landscape, spreading from coastal urban centers to heartland communities once considered bastions of faith.

    The generational shifts are particularly noteworthy. For the first time in recorded history, Gen Z men are attending church at higher rates than Gen Z women—not just because more young men are coming to church, but because unprecedented numbers of young women are leaving. As Stetzer observes, “The biggest group of Gen Zers disconnected are Gen Z women.”

    The Unexpected Opportunity

    Yet amid these concerning trends, something unexpected has emerged since 2020. Stetzer describes it as “the meteor called 2020″—a disruption to the steady decline of religious engagement that has sent religious trends “five different directions at the same time.”

    These disruptions include surprising developments:

    • Gen Z men re-engaging with church
    • Gen Z teens showing greater spiritual openness than in recent memory
    • A plateau in the previously relentless growth of religious “nones”
    • A significant increase in Bible sales (22% according to the Wall Street Journal)
    • Rising spiritual hunger, especially among younger generations

    “I’m more open to God today than I was before the pandemic,” report 34% of Boomers and nearly twice that percentage among Gen Z. As Stetzer emphasizes, “Something is going on, and I don’t want us to miss it.”

    The Gap Between Opportunity and Action

    Despite these encouraging signs of spiritual openness, church planting efforts have not yet risen to meet the moment. “Church Planting activity is not yet aligned with church planting opportunity,” Stetzer notes. The latest research shows only about 7% of churches are at a “reproducing” level, with virtually none reaching the highest “multiplying” level of growth.

    This disconnect between spiritual hunger and church multiplication represents both a challenge and an opportunity. As Stetzer passionately argues, “Revival is almost always accompanied by church planting multiplication. I’m convinced there’s no hope for revival without a heart for church planting.”

    Five Challenges for Revitalization

    To seize this pivotal moment and move toward greater Gospel impact, here are five essential challenges for today’s church:

    1. Acknowledge Reality with Brutal Honesty

    As Stetzer reminds us, “Facts are our friends in missiology.” We cannot effectively address challenges we refuse to see. The first step toward revitalization is embracing the uncomfortable statistics about declining participation, particularly among younger generations and women. Only by acknowledging where we truly stand can we formulate appropriate responses.

    Challenge: Conduct an honest assessment of your church’s current reality. Measure not just attendance numbers but engagement levels across demographic groups, with special attention to reaching young women who represent the fastest-growing segment of religious disengagement.

    1. Respond to Increased Spiritual Openness

    The data reveals unprecedented spiritual hunger, particularly among younger Americans. “Gen Z teens are more spiritually open today than any time that we’ve seen in our data,” Stetzer notes. Yet many churches continue with approaches that fail to connect with this hunger.

    Challenge: Develop intentional strategies to engage spiritual seekers. Create environments and opportunities specifically designed for spiritual exploration, emphasizing authenticity over polished performances. Consider how your church might serve as a spiritual resource center for your community, not just a worship destination.

    1. Prioritize Multiplication Over Maintenance

    Research consistently shows that “church planting is the best evangelistic investment of energy.” Yet many congregations remain focused on maintaining existing programs rather than reproducing their ministry.

    Challenge: Shift resources toward multiplication. Move beyond “NASCAR patch” approaches where multiple organizations claim credit for the same church plants without taking true responsibility. Instead, develop a concrete plan to dedicate at least 10% of your church’s budget and leadership capacity toward starting new congregations or ministry sites within the next three years.

    1. Address the Gender Engagement Gap

    The unprecedented exodus of young women from churches demands urgent attention. This shift represents not just a statistical anomaly but a profound challenge to the future of faith communities.

    Challenge: Examine how your church engages, empowers, and elevates women in ministry. Conduct listening sessions with young women to understand their spiritual needs and perspectives. Ensure female voices are represented in leadership and create mentorship pathways between generations of women in your congregation.

    1. Move From Good to Great to Greater

    Stetzer challenges churches to progress beyond mere survival or modest growth: “I want you to hear this, right? The non-sacrificing version of church planting sponsorship won’t get us to a movement.” Incremental improvements will not address the scope of current challenges.

    Challenge: Identify one area where your church has settled for “good enough” and commit to excellence. Whether in worship, discipleship, community engagement, or leadership development, create a concrete action plan to move from acceptable to exceptional in at least one ministry area within the next year.

    The Call to Greater Impact

    The data reveals a unique moment in American religious history—a time when decades of decline appear to give way to new spiritual engagement patterns. This represents a critical window of opportunity that churches must not miss.

    “A wide door for effective ministry is open for me, yet many adversaries,” Paul wrote in 1 Corinthians 16:9. Today’s church faces a similar reality—extraordinary opportunity alongside significant challenges. The question is whether we will recognize and respond to this moment with the courage and conviction it demands.

    As Stetzer concludes, “We weren’t meant to be tending the grave, you’ve called us to something good, something great and something greater.” The future of American Christianity may well depend on how we answer this call to move beyond maintenance toward multiplication, beyond survival toward significance, and beyond comfortable ministry toward courageous mission.

    The opportunity stands before us. The data shows spiritual hunger among a generation often dismissed as disinterested. The greatest revitalization need is now—and it starts with each of us who claim Christianity as our faith embracing the difficult but essential work of transformation.

    Will we seize this moment to move from good to great to greater? The future of the American church hangs in the balance.

     

    Originally published on the Church Vitality Network.